Anticoagulants
(blood thinners) LONG TERM: http://healthfully.org/rc/id10.html (12/18/14)
If the number of platelets is too
low, excessive bleeding can occur; however, if the number of
platelets is too high, blood clots can form (thrombosis),
which may obstruct blood vessels and result in such events as a stroke, myocardial infarction (MI), pulmonary embolism or the blockage of
blood vessels to other parts of the body, such as kidneys the extremities of
the arms or legs. To prevent these
health
issues pharma markets 8 families of anticoagulants: vitamin K inhibitors, platelet inhibitors, anti-thrombin
protein therapeutics, direct thrombin inhibitors, Xa inhibitors, and synthetic
pentasaccharide inhibitors, fibrin inhibitors, and animal type clot inhibitors
from insects, lamprey, etc. Anticoagulants
constitute the 3rd most profitable prophylactic drug intervention after statins
and hypertension drugs. Is the current
level of intervention justified; and when justified, what ought to be
taken?
Rather than again visit the topic
of credibility of the pill pushers, please read Marketing Science & Side Effects. As
Prof, Dr.
Marcia Angell
states: “We certainly are
in a health
care crisis,... If we had set out
to
design the worst system that we could imagine, we couldn't have imagined one as
bad as we have.” Her President’s
Lecture & book on how pharma deceives us makes this point through
examples. For an explanation of
how
pharma manipulates the practice of medicine click on junk treatments.
Bias journal articles are the norm[1] and informed
consent has become misinformed.
Aspirin, the choice of our
grandparents, has fallen victim to the production of miss-information
by pharma[2]. Aspirin
as an anticoagulant has been replaced by 8 types of patented drugs. However
the convincing evidence for this is
lacking. In a review of the 2 leading
anticoagulants, The American Heart Association (AHA) concluded
that, “The primary outcome
measure and the
mortality data do not support the primary hypotheses that warfarin [Coumadin]
and Plavix [clopidogrel] is superior to aspirin.” Aspirin
in the medicinal dose of 325-975
mg is superior to Warfarin,
Plavix, and others
because it is an effective anticoagulant, best for heart attack prevention (lowers
deaths
51%), and causes less serious
hemorrhaging. Thus the studies using low dose aspirin (75
mgs) are flawed. Aspirin
also reduces the risk of the most common types of cancers by over 30%, & promotes
the survival of most stages I, II, & III of those cancers through the
apoptosis (the death of abnormal cells), e.g., colon cancer survival up
74%, & breast cancer up
66%. Wikipedia
wrote:
“NSAIDs aside from aspirin,
both newer selective COX-2 inhibitors [Celebrex, Vioxx] and traditional
anti-inflammatories, increase the risk
of myocardial
infarction
and stroke.[9][10]….
NSAIDs aside from aspirin are associated with a doubled risk of symptomatic
heart failure in patients without a history of cardiac disease.” The AHA
has a similar
warning.
Consider a day on NSAIDs as equal to smoking a pack of cigarettes.[3] Aspirin
also lowers the risk of Alzheimer’s diseases 60%. Aspirin should be the drug of choice. Anticoagulants ought
not to be used after major
surgery:
“The fatal pulmonary embolism rate was 0.1% to 0.2% even in patients who
received no prophylaxis. This is an order of magnitude lower than that which is
generally quoted, and therefore the potential
benefit of prophylaxis is very small and does not justify the risks… as
shown by autopsy.” The atrial
fibrillation use of anticoagulants is based on marketing science.
Coumadin (Warfarin, a
vitamin K antagonists): This
oral anticoagulant is derived from coumarin,
which is found in many plants, and was originally used as a rodenticide since
1948. In the 1950s it was found to be effective and relatively safe for preventing embolism in many disorders. “It
was approved in
1954 and is the most widely prescribed anticoagulant drug in North America. It
takes at least 48 to 72 hours for the
anticoagulant effect to develop. Where an immediate effect is required heparin is given.
Warfarin is used for patients with deep-vein
thrombosis (DVT), pulmonary
embolism (PE), atrial
fibrillation(AF), and mechanical prosthetic
heart valves. Warfarin’s half
life is 40 hours. Warfarin and related 4-hydroxycoumarin-containing molecules decrease blood coagulation by inhibiting vitamin K epoxide reductase, an enzyme that recycles oxidized vitamin K1 to
its reduced form after it has
participated in the carboxylation of several blood coagulation proteins, mainly
prothrombin and factor VII. Despite
being labeled a vitamin K antagonist, [2] warfarin does not antagonize the action of
vitamin K1, but rather antagonizes vitamin K1recycling,
depleting active vitamin K1[3]“ Wikipedia. Typical results are in a 2013 study comparing Edoxaban to warfarin in 21,105
patients for high risk with fibrillation) for 2.8 years with endpoints of stroke
or systemic embolism found for
warfarin 1.5% per year had those endpoints.
But major bleeding (2 or more pints of blood transfusion) was 3.43% per year. And excluded to avoid negative results was
the incidents of MI, for which warfarin has little effect upon. Low dose Edoxaban
fared about the same. Side
effects include the very serious calcification of tissues, a key
element in hypertension and CVD (in
the arteries calcification and
buildup of plaque are their causes). “Warfarin causes cholesterol
embolism (athero-embolism) resulting from the release of cholesterol from
plaque. It travels along with the blood steam (embolism) to other places in the body, where it
obstructs blood
vessels…. causes skin
symptoms (usually livedo reticularis), gangrene of the extremities and sometimes renal
failure; problems with
other organs may arise, depending on the site at which the cholesterol crystals
enter the bloodstream” Wiki .
“Several epidemiological studies have also implicated
warfarin use in valvular and vascular calcification. … a 60% increased risk of
osteoporosis-related fracture in men” Wiki.
Despite its effectiveness there
are major
shortcomings. It has been used occasionally after heart
attacks (myocardial
infarctions), but is far less
effective at preventing new thromboses in coronary arteries. Prevention
of clotting in arteries is usually undertaken with antiplatelet drugs such as aspirin,
which act by a different mechanism from Warfarin
(which normally has no effect on platelet function). Warfarin accounts
for one
third of hospitalizations, an
estimated annual 33,000 for adverse drug reactions of hemorrhaging. Several times
more major events go unreported because of lack of a legal reporting
requirement, failure to associate the event as drug induced, not knowing which
drug is the cause, and death. “Several studies have
demonstrated a link between warfarin
use and osteoporosis-related fracture.” .Warfarin interacts with a list of over 100 drugs, herbs and
foods--see Worst
Pill for a list. “Most of interactions will greatly increase
the effect of Warfarin by reducing the metabolism of Warfarin in the body, thus increasing
greatly the risk of hemorrhaging.” The maintenance dose of Warfarin can fluctuate significantly
depending on the amount of vitamin K1 in the diet, thus frequent testing for
clotting is required. Once the highest
risk group is removed from
studies the touted benefits evaporate.[4] The need for dangerous, expensive,
prophylactic drug intervention also evaporates.”
Alternative to Warfarin (knockoffs) Acenocoumarol & phenprocoumon unlike warfarin do not need monitoring, such as Phenindione,
Atromentin,
dabigatran (Pradaxa)
and rivaroxaban.
However since they cannot be reversed like warfarin, there are more fatal
bleeds. FDA report for 2011, much more widely prescribed Warfarin caused 72
deaths, Pradaxa 542 deaths.
Clopidogrel (INN) (Plavix),
the
most profitable of anticoagulants with 48 million American taking it daily in
2006, and total US sales of over $60 billion by 2010. Plavix is an oral, thienopyridine class antiplatelet agent that irreversibly
inhibits[5]
the P2Y12 receptor, an adenosine diphosphate (ADP)
chemoreceptor on platelet cell membranes. Meta-analysis
showed insignificant
8% reduction in major events in non-smokers, & 29% in smokers. Warfarin
& Plavix are effective only for smokers. Unlike warfarin, bleeding cannot
be
easily reversed. Because
Warfarin and Plavix do not have an antiplatelet effect (the main cause for
thrombi), there were several clinical trials with low dose aspirin and Plavix
and other trials with Warfarin. This
combination resulted in increased hemorrhaging and the failed to significantly
protect from MI more just low-dose aspirin, Cochrane, and the AHA
agreed. Common side effects include
hemorrhaging,
upper GI discomfort, ulcers, gastritis, rash, osteoporosis,
thin skin, and diarrhea; the same for Warfarin.
Direct
factor Xa inhibitors ('xabans') are
a class of anticoagulant drugs which act
directly upon Factor X in the coagulation cascade, without using antithrombin as a mediator.[1] The first of
this class is an extracts of Mexican leehes, the second is derived from a
tick. Currently marketed are Apixban,
Betrixaban, Edoxaban, Otamixan, and Rivaroxaban.
Unlike Warfarin they are predictable, but they interact with stains, and
there is no way to reverse the anticoagulant effect. The synthetic
pentasccharides inhibitors of factor, Fondaparinux, and Idraparinux, work
by antithrombin activation.
Recommendations: “It is not true that most cases of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) in medical
patients can be prevented.” Aspirin as an antiplatelet
reduces risk of stroke, embolism,
and MI[6]; as an anti-inflammatory drug reduces for
atherosclerosis with its related strokes and MIs, Alzheimer’s disease, and
rheumatoid & osteoarthritis; and because of activation of necrosis factor
reduces risk of cancer risk &
increases survival; and these benefits are dose dependent. Thus take 325
mg
aspirin daily for prevent clots, or 325 with meals to prevent atherosclerosis & its ischemic events. Other than
a 4% increased
long-term risk of gastric ulcer, aspirin is safe. That 4% is much lower than the 3.43% of major bleeding per year with warfarin.[7] Risk is greatly reduces
with elimination of Helicobacter Pylori bacteria. When all
causes of death are included, anticoagulants don’t save lives, see WARIS study. JK from 1992 to 1996
took under physician advice eight 325 mg coated aspirin per day for chronic
back pain (inflammation) with no heart burn, and has since then takes 325-650 mgs
daily, though his blood pressure is 125 over 73 a strong evidence of the lack
of atherosclerosis and he is in his 7th decade. Low dose is ineffective due to
tolerance. Aspirin was the standard
arthritis treatment for decades starting at 2.5 grams. Papers on aspirin: benefits and history, on cancer, and on atherogenesis.
[1] Bias average 32%, 2008 NEJM. 74 FDA-registered trials of anti-depressant compared
to the raw obtained through the Freedom of Information Act. Review system is
a facade because the raw data
is never supplied with the journal submission. Those who fund the studies own the results.
[2] Counter to pharm, stomach bleeds are not more than for other
NSAIDS. Goodman & Gilman 11th
Ed. P. 690: “Many clinicians favor the use of other NSAIDs perceived to have
better gastro-intestinal tolerability, even though this perception remains unproven
by convincing clinical trials.”
[3] Like cancer and tobacco, the results take years to become apparent
among the low risk group. There is every
reason given the biology behind the process to expect the increased MI
for all the NSAIDs, even the low risk group--but for aspirin. And as stated
above the risk varies according
to NSAID—which includes the widely advertised Celebrex, whose risk is likely
the greatest among the currently available NSAIDs. The other two large PhARMA
funded studies are VIGOR 2000 and APPROVe in 2001 for Vioxx. Both were equal
bad; and similar results were
had for Celebrex.
[4] “We were able to determine
the minimal
clinical difference of warfarin therapy for the prevention of stroke from the
perspective of patients with non-valvular atrial fibrillation. Their
differences were much smaller than those
that have been implied by some experts.”
[5] This
makes hemorrhaging far more serious than Warfarin which can be treated with
vitamin K. The guidelines require blood
work on clotting has driven doctors away from the safer warfarin—more pharma
working guideline for their profits.
[6]
The highest risk group,
unstable angina, had a 236% reduction in death, and cardiac event 152%--a 1994 meta-study
using
325 mg.
[7]
There is a pile of junk science using tricks such
as endoscopic search for lesion in the stomach to count as proof of the danger
of taking aspirin. Pharmacology text
book, Goodman & Gilman 11th Ed, 2006, p 690: “many clinicians favor the use of other
NSAIDs perceived to have better gastrointestinal tolerability, even though this
perception remains unproven by convincing clinical trials.”
|